Trad Gang

Main Boards => PowWow => Topic started by: Joshua Long on August 28, 2011, 05:22:00 PM

Title: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Joshua Long on August 28, 2011, 05:22:00 PM
I am really for a loss on this one.  I had my longbow dialed in through July/first part of August and now shots are consistently hitting left with greater variation up/down.  We had high humidity during that time and has since lowered considerably.  The arrows in question are POC and I shoot right handed.  

I also shot these arrows in my recurve which is less picky and they did the same thing.  The Surewoods that I normally shoot from my recurve have not shown any effect from the humidity change.

So can I get away with blaming the weather?  :dunno:
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Mike Vines on August 28, 2011, 05:26:00 PM
If it were me, I would blame a small critter and take out my frustration on them.

I had a hard time with cedar getting and staying straight (not to mention an allergy to the dust), so I switched over to all douglas fir direct from Surewood Arrow Shafts, and never had a problem with anything since.  Always stay straight, I don't even have to straighten them when I first pull them from the stack.
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Benny Nganabbarru on August 28, 2011, 05:33:00 PM
No. Humidity and intense monsoonal downpours will not affect an arrow's spine, providing the arrow is properly sealed. I wrote of Geoff Arnold's experience in the 1960s, in TBM, out at Victoria River Downs, when he shot at a donkey, and was appalled to see the terrible cork-screwing flight of that arrow all the way to the donkey's spine, dropping it on the spot. He learned his lesson about sealed arrows then. Basically, the arrow never recovered from paradox.
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Joshua Long on August 28, 2011, 05:53:00 PM
Ben,
I checked both set of arrows the POC have been shot considerably more and have scuffs and abrasions.  They need re-sealed I would say.

The Surewoods are practically new arrows fully sealed.

Thanks,

Joshua
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Bjorn on August 28, 2011, 06:03:00 PM
Spine check them and see if there is a change. I have not found weather to affect arrow shafting and I have left sealed arrows in water puddles just to check them out. In the summertime the arrows I use for 3D are mostly unfinished-just apply the fletch directly to the bare wood.
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Don Stokes on August 28, 2011, 06:44:00 PM
Joshua, it's highly unlikely that it's the weather. Sorry.    :)  

There's no such thing as waterproof, but changes take place so slowly in reasonably well sealed shafts that I've never noticed any effect due to changes in humidity. I live in Mississippi, and we are famous for our humidity. Also, POC shafts are all heartwood, which is saturated with natural chemicals and is very slow to take on moisture.
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Art B on August 28, 2011, 07:54:00 PM
Spine will change if you let 'em get hot/warm. Was it pretty hot when you was shooting? Arrows lay out in the sun?  Or you had 'em in a dark/black quiver exposed to the sun.......Art
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: lpcjon2 on August 28, 2011, 08:21:00 PM
Do I see a can of poly being bought in your future? YES. And check how and where you store them.
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Joshua Long on August 28, 2011, 08:59:00 PM
I don't have a way to spine test, but that would be the ticket to find out.

My house is not humidity controlled so they get natural variations in humidity.  They are stored upright in cut down blueprint tubes.  

I shot those arrows first today in mild mid 70's weather.  

Yes, I will need some poly.

I checked the bow over and the brace height is the same.  

All I know is my point of impact has shifted 6" to the left at 20yds with expanded groups.

Thanks for all your input.

Joshua
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Benny Nganabbarru on August 29, 2011, 03:49:00 AM
You're storing them fine. Good wooden arrows can handle anything the Territory can throw at them. I lost an arrow in a tree at school, and by the time the kids found it and knocked it down, it had endured a few months of monsoon, heat and humidity. It was perfectly straight, and still flies great.

Has anything changed with your shooting? New string? Was it a gradual change, or a sudden change? Have you been coming to full-draw? Have you been tired or ill or stressed?
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Joshua Long on August 29, 2011, 01:50:00 PM
I can't say anything has changed with my draw that I can detect.  Same string. I guess it has been a rather sudden change.

I attended a 3d shoot in July and shot great.  Now the last two weeks everything has changed.  I know my confidence has taken a hit, but I am keeping my normal form.

I did change my target going to 1" black dot down from a 1-1/2" black dot.  I also have been wearing my contacts more to shoot rather than my glasses.
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: Bjorn on August 29, 2011, 02:34:00 PM
For me changing between contacts and glasses can make a big difference.........glasses give me better vision but with trifocals some of the sight pictures are weird.
With contacts I don't get that. If you have been changing back and forth that may be the answer.
Title: Re: Humidity changes affecting wood arrow tuning???
Post by: TommyBoy on August 29, 2011, 02:42:00 PM
Yep they can do that - even if they are sealed well.  In the dog days of summer in Missouri (July/Aug) I usually go up 5 lbs in spine. The heat just makes the shafts a little more "noodley".  Seems like you got them dialed in for the summer, but they might be a little too stiff for you now.  Try changing out your points to something a little heavier and you should be fine.