I jut want to pause and thank all of you for your contributions of wisdom. I am taking what each of you have said and looking back at my hunt with reflection. I am already formulating a new 'strategy' for the next time I go. Even though I can look back and see that I did the best I knew how to do at the time, I can't help but get excited about the 'next time' and how it will go as I build experience. One 'curse' of such a trip is that my mind wants more of the wilderness and I am dreaming more than ever about getting back out again!
The scent issue is an interesting one. When that bull came out to feed in front of me the wind was just right. He only knew I was there when I tried to stand up and move in even closer to get a better photo. Wow! What a sight it is to see such a beautiful, and large, magnificent animal crash up a steep mountain side above a meadow! I have written about my method of hunting whitetail in other areas of this forum. This is something I feel more and more confident about. I left the tree stands 5 or so years ago and have hunted the ground since. I have actually had no more difficulty getting close to wary northern deer in that time. Both my partner and I use very clean approach with showers or sauna before the hunt. Our clothing is 100% wool and kept outside or in closed boxes with balsam boughs. We smoke ourselves and our clothing regularly. I have many brush blinds up to 3 miles walk in and will often stop and build a small smoky smudge before I proceed the final few hundred yards to the stand. Of course, wind direction is THE MOST IMPORTANT factor, but we are often having face-to-face ground level action at 10-15 yards and there is nothing like that....its thrilling in a way I never got up in the tree. Of course, we do all the right scouting and set up in the spring to increase our odds in an area with some of the lowest deer densities in the country. (as Greg Miller writes in one of his bowhunting books, hunting in areas with low deer numbers means your not going to expect to see deer on a stand every time) The use of smoke, I believe, is not a cover up, but does something else. I used to trap and it is a regular practice for fox trappers to 'smoke' the traps to 'kill' the scent. It does something...
Its this type of approach to deer hunting that I wanted to expand into my other big game hunts. To learn methods that rely on hunting skill, hard work, and determination to increase the odds in the hunter's favor. I could slip over to Ontario to hunt a spring pre-baited stand...and I have nothing against that AT ALL, ...its just not the way I want to PERSONALLY take bear on a regular basis- I don't rule out a bait hunt and will probably do one eventually. (Baiting of bears goes back for centuries and native peoples would often kill bear in baited deadfalls).
Speaking of Ontario, I love the bush country and often go fishing up there by canoe (my parents own a cabin above the Saulte). One of my dream hunts (you'll see I suffer from romantic visions) is of an 'old fashion' moose hunt by canoe. My hunting partner and I have built wood and canvas canoes. I would love to camp by canvas tent and call during the day along a northern water route. The difficulty is that you have to hunt through outfitters. I wonder if any reader out there on the forum has ideas about hunting Ontario or has done such a hunt as I describe?
Anyway, thanks for reading along with my ramblings and thank each and every one of you for your helpful campfire advice!
Dan
Best my iphone could do in low light...