To my notion, you didn't blow anything, Ken. That shelf is indeed a wide one. A fellow could have a decent (close) tune and the back of the arrow still wouldn't clear "that" shelf. Raising the nocking point may help some. Raising the nocking point won't make the arrow act any weaker, but, it may alleviate some contact on the shelf.
If I owned that bow, I'd probably shoot it off an elevated rest, or take a rasp and sandpaper to the shelf too. 8^)