Joey,
Congrats on your new (old) '58 Kodiak. They are a great shooting bow. Infact, I've been refinishing mine.....have one more coat of wipe-on-poly and then put on a new leather grip and she'll be ready to go. After sanding off the old, yellowed finish, that white glass sure looks fantastic!
As for arrows, I have been shooting mainly CE Heritage 250's with 50 grain brass inserts and the old Bear razorheads(my bow is 59#). I also shoot woodies that I've made, again with the old Bear razorheads.
Bob