Originally posted by chiger:
Sweet Karl,
You've just built a knife using 2 of my favorite materials in the world. Walnut and W2!
Wish we could see the figure in that crotch wood better. It's cool stuff.
I know you're a 5160 guy and I ain't tryin' to pick a fight. ;~) But....I think W1 and W2 in particular make the best blades. And when it's forged by a smith with your skill, well you get blades that look like that.
Great job getting a hamon that distinctive. Not easy even clay quenching with W2 and that one is great.
By the way, love the double bolster. The bluing is very fitting. That's one that Bowie would be proud to carry.
JD, thanks for the thoughtful critique.
Yep, I'm a 5160 guy 'cause the supply of 1 inch square 5160 I have was all made from one melt in 1984. It's higher in carbon than the normal off-the-shelf 5160 and was all made from raw materials.
I get performance from it like no other 5160 I've ever seen.
My most recent customer testimonial stated he "took five deer from field to freezer" before he had to touch up the blade, which by the way, on this steel, only takes a few well-placed strokes and you're back in the game.
That Walnut has, besides the crotch "flame", these vertical striations about every 1/2 inch.
It gives the handle this tortoise shell appearance.
I really like it.
I've got plenty of W1, W2 and 1084.
I like them all!