Hey, Clay-bet your friend likes the knife. From the pictures, looks like you got a good fit up with the guard, both on the blade side as well as the antler. I agree with you that the dropped choil would have brought it more in line with the handle material given to you, but you were a bit limited if that's the piece of antler you had to use. Glad the forging of the guard worked out well for you. I've done that a time or two myself to get me closer to size and is certainly helpful.
Looking forward to seeing the next knives you come up with. Hope you and the family have a good Christmas, my friend.
Jeremy