i like them all, but i have noticed with natural oil finishes on the 1/4 sawn, that it always seems to stay a little "spikey" or "hairy", (i geuss its just minute fibres sticking up) no matter how much i sanded and finished it- that could all be resolved with a poly type finish though.- in retrospect the sealing poly finish is probably better - to stabilise the m.c. as hickory is so prone to m.c. changes.