Agree on Traditional Outdoor Supply in Sand Lake. In fact, I'm heading over there in about an hour! LOL
It's not a big store, but Tom has a lot of trad only stuff jammed in there and I stop in probably twice a month. Today I need a new bowstringer because my old one got knotted up, Masters of the Barebow II and maybe a tab and maybe some bow grip wraps.
Tom also has traditional blackpowder supplies, which aren't easy to find in most stores.
Here's the number for Traditional Outdoor Supply
616-636-2697
The address for mapquest is 53 E. Lake Street, Sand Lake, Mi. 49434
Tom is a super guy and if you're anywhere nearby, make sure to stop in.
Jays is also a great store, but on the other end of the spectrum. Jay's is a mega store, with 500 plus compounds, crossbows, boats, ATV's, etc. In fact, I think it's the largest non-chain/single owner hunting stores in the country. You can spend 6 hours at Jays. Jays is a great place to gun shop because the selection is huge.
Nothing against Jays at all, but Tom is unbeatable on trad archery knowledge. I'll end up chewing Tom's ear for an hour today. It's tough to do that in busy a super store, if you know what I mean.