Thanks very much everyone,
Bear Heart (Tim's) phone coaching session was one of the easiest ever for me. He was right there but, not quite shaving.
As Tim mentioned, the secret to sharpening anything is that you must get the broadhead or knife blade as sharp as you possibly can with the coarsest abrasive you start with, be it a file or a stone. This is absolutely critical and is without question the single most common mistake that people make when learning to sharpen anything. (progressing through the grits too quickly).
The bevels of a double bevel blade have to be ground/filed until a true intersection is formed at the cutting edge... if this is not accomplished at the coarsest stage, progressing through finer grits will only polish the bevels of the dull edge, and not make it one bit sharper.
Since the cutting edge itself is microscopic, the only way to tell that you're ready to move to a finer grit stone is by seeing if the blade will shave or at least try very hard to shave. It may not mow hair cleanly but, it should aggressively grab the hairs and cut at least a couple of them when you test it. If not, stay with the file or coarse stone until it does. Only then you can move on to finer grits to refine the edge created by the coarse stone or file.
The laminated tip heads are the toughest to sharpen the first time because so much metal needs to be removed from the triple thick tip section. I recommend filing the tip section first to save time but, if you (like me) are not very good with a file, then the next fastest way to set the bevels is with an X-coarse or coarse diamond stone or as some have suggested some 120 grit wet/dry auto body sandpaper. (use lots of water). Same deal, get the blade to shave with the coarsest grit then progress to finer grits to refine the edge to hair mowing sharp.
As for which sharpener is the better choice, that depends. The broadhead sharpener is the workhorse of the two and would be my choice for very dull heads or laminated tip heads, and with the right stones it will get a broadhead just crazy sharp. Just remember the above rule- sharp as you can get on the coarsest grit before moving on to finer grits.
The knife sharpener is more of a finesse tool and while it will absolutely "tune" heads that have been previously sharpened, I wouldn't want to do an out of the pack laminated head start to finish with it. If you can file them first, then the knife sharpener will finish them up beautifully. The knife sharpener is quickly becoming my sharpener of choice for resharpening very large heads like the Grizzly El Grandes and Ace broadheads that have been filed or sharpened previously.
Thanks again to everyone for helping out with good advice and if any of you are having trouble getting the results you're looking for with either sharpener, PLEASE don't hesitate to call me. I answer the phone till 8 PM Eastern, 7 days.
Ron
80 561-4339