Curt, this is a good/entertaining thread, thanks for starting it.
My thoughts take them or leave them, I don’t much care: I use two blade (Grizzly), three blade (Woodsman), and four blade (Eclipse, two blade with a bleeder) broadheads, intermix and change them without thinking much about it, and the broadheads weights vary between 125 and 190 grains. I match the weight and therefore the type of broadhead to the arrow that flies best from a given bow. The most important factor for me is accuracy, if you put the arrow where it should be this discussion is moot. Accuracy is followed by good arrow flight, if you have that, ample penetration will follow. Without penetration, this discussion is moot. Next is a sharp broadhead, both before and after the shot. Many people put a razor thin, super sharpe, and weak edge on the broadhead and it gets duller (is duller a word) then a butter knife when it hits a bone. I find my broadheads stay sharper after hitting bone with a little less of an angle on the edge then most people use.
Some of you guys need to lighten up a little bit, your too serious and taking the fun out of it. This made me realize that the broadhead topic is a little like religion, there are lots of them out there, lots of people think theirs is the only “right one”, and everybody should accept their choice.
A final thought, personally, I think many of you are spending too much time worrying about why your broadhead is the best and justifying that is, when the time would be better spent practicing to make sure it hits where it should.