I'll wade in just for novelty's sake. As you stated, it's a highly subjective topic. Here's my "top" 3, broken down by price.
Budget = Quinn's
Mid = Dryad Orion, RER, or Whisperstick
No Budget = Schafer or Morrison
Again, those are just the ones that come to my mind immediately, and sticking with recurves. There are a ton of quality bowyers out there today. You won't go wrong with most of them. For most of us, the "magic" bow usually boils down to the grip we like best. All the bows listed above are excellent shooters, but there are dozens more that are just as sweet!