Some success today...
Cleaned with acetone, dipped, fisheyed as usual, let dry (somewhat)cleaned with acetone again, all paint off, then dipped again which left a reasonable base coat. Second coat tomorrow.
Lots of work for something that should never be a problem in the first place.
Also, took a CE that I have been using as stumper and it was never dipped; its probably a a year or 18 months old. Figured any oil, etc. would be long gone. Stripped off the feathers, cleaned it and it fisheyed just like a new one!!!
Will give the "smoothie" a try, appreciate the tip.
I am going to look into switching arrow shafts.
HP, thanks for the offer.
Thanks all!
Bob