Somethings not right. I've fletched several dozen Doug Fir's and Sitka Spruce shafts, sealed with tung oil, using Boning tape... never had a problem.
Maybe the conditions were too humid for the oil to dry completely after 24 hours? Also, I'm drifty enough to have tried a feather and forgot to peel the tape, but I might have that distinction to myself.
Let us know some more, it absolutely should work fine.
P.S. - never had a failure due to tale in 4 or 5 years of using them, unless it were my error.