I've had 58" Mag's, 60" Mag's, a 60" MOAB, a 62" MOAB and a couple 66" III's.
I've traded or sold all but the 62" MOAB and 66" III after settling in on 3 under. The other Thunderstick's were fine with split finger, but not for 3 under with my draw.
At least for me, the 62" MOAB is a dream shooter and the 66" isn't far behind. With 3 under, the MOAB is dead silent and my III has a tiny thunk.
Both shoot where you look.
After shooting and owning a bunch of bows, I've narrowed my bow herd to Toelke Whip's, Whisperstik Mojo's and Voodoo's and my MOAB and III. Although JD from Whisperstik has a new little gem of a bow coming out that I just shot and ordered, but I'll let him tell you about it. All I can say is, you won't believe what comes in such a small package, even with 3 under and a longer draw, it's pretty incredible. And I have an Owl Bow and a Dryad Kiowa on order.
Of all those, the MOAB shoots equally to the others and that's great company.
If I have any complaint about Thundersticks, it's that the leather/suede material on the grip doesn't wear well and the finishing coat doesn't compare to my Toelke's or Whisperstik's. There's a little glare on the ones I've owned. But that being said, both deer I killed this fall were with my MOAB.
I had JD from Whisperstik refinish my MOAB and put on his premium leather grip and now it's cosmetically as nice as the others.
When it comes to hunting the peak chase period of the rut, I just can't seem to walk out the cabin door without the MOAB in my hand, despite having my super shooting Toelke's and Whisperstik's.
I think for next year, I'm going to put all my bows on a piece of paper and pull a name out of the hat before I go out, otherwise I'll always gravitate to the MOAB. That's how confident I am with that bow.
Otherwise, it's not fair to the other bows, the other bowyers and frankly, myself.