Getting the right tool.

[jfelkins]

Howdy all. I'd love advice from some guys that have had success elk hunting. I currently have a LH 45lb TD recurve and a 45lb Pearson Hunter. I'm planning to hunt elk in 2012. I'd love to be able to buy another bow but need too much other quality gear for a DIY backpack elk hunt.

If you were in my shoes how would you go from the bows I have to a good elk hunting bow?

I want a good tool, I'm not looking for a piece of bling. Also, I'm currently shooting carbons that are about 494 grains and 175 gr wensel woodsman elites. Id also like a light bow, I don't want to lug a battle axe around.

Am I being too picky?!    

Thanks again.

John

[Rob DiStefano]

how 'bout just getting a new set of 50-60# limbs for yer chekmate, make up some heavier arrows, practice a whole bunch?

[Ragnarok Forge]

45 lbs while light will do the job.  It is a lot more important to up the arrow weight your using.  I would get the total arrow weight up around 600 grains to improve penetration.  Practice until you can hit a tennis ball every time at 20 yards and don't shoot any further than 25.  Wait for the right angle and right shot. Put your money into arrows not a new bow.  That and get dead serious about your practice.

[thump]

Quote"45 lbs while light will do the job. It is a lot more important to up the arrow weight your using. I would get the total arrow weight up around 600 grains to improve penetration. Practice until you can hit a tennis ball every time at 20 yards and don't shoot any further than 25. Wait for the right angle and right shot. Put your money into arrows not a new bow. That and get dead serious about your practice."   Even if you do move up in draw weight

[Bill Kissner]

You are going to get a few replies saying 45 pounds are enough for elk because someone got a pass through with less. 45 pounds will kill an elk with a perfect hit no doubt but in my book it is about the lowest poundage you should use. Like Rob said, you would be better off with heavier limbs and a heavier arrow IMO.

[YORNOC]

I agree, if you can... try and go heavier. You can't control if you hit or glance a rib or bone. You want to be ready for the worst scenario. An elk is not small.

[Onehair]

Borrow a heavier bow.

[jfelkins]

i can get up to 600 grains pretty easy (i think). 50 lbs with 600 grains would be a good set up with the right shot? Thanks fellas.