Thanks for the compliments guys, it really means alot to hear good things. Especially when I didn't get started in making arrows till just 6 months ago. I use it to relax in the evening, and my 2 sons (7 and 5) have even gotten involved in the process with me. It's great family fun in the winter.
As for what stain, I used Minwax Ebony as the dark stain (2 coats), and then for the lighter color, I mixed 3 different stains I had left over from a job, so it's a crap shoot on that one.