Help and opinions with nanners....

[LookMomNoSights]

Tell me what you think - I put some nanners on some surewood shafting....they are low pros and about 5.75 long.  3 of them!  My jo-jan is set up to be around 9 or 10 degrees helical.  I used Duco cement.  They fly good and are quiet.  Now,  I put the same fletch on some GT 5755's with fletch tape on a wrap.....and these sound like an air raid siren all the way to the target!  What gives!?  What do you think?  Am I too helical for nanners?   As of now Im thinking of going back to 5 inch shields for the carbon unless someone has some great insight....  

[Huntschool]

You may be...  different strokes...

How are those AD Trads?

[magnus]

Is the diameter of the shafts different?

[LookMomNoSights]

Bruce....I havent posted in a bit here but Im on now and was just about to send you a P.M. as I have those AD's packed up and ready to ship back to ya.....thanks a ton and I truely appreciate you going out of your way in what is apparently  typical Trad Ganger fashion to help me out!           You didnt have to but you did....Thank You!  I liked those very much too by the way.  Put a 175 grain point up there seeming to give me the best flight!  Seemed kinda heavey but what the heck right!?   Worked Great!  Most likely be my next purchase in shafting.  

[LookMomNoSights]

Yes Magnus!  The wood is 11/32....the Gts are what, .246!?   think thats it?

[magnus]

That might have something to do with it. You might be getting more helical with the smaller shaft. I don't know for certain. Others will chime in I'm sure.