Light and fast vs heavy and slow

[JDunlap]

Originally posted by Ragnarok Forge:
JDunlap,  Heavier arrows do fly better in the wind.  Especially if you use HFOC and smaller fletchings.

Whittler,  A body in motions tends to stay in motion.  The heavier the body the longer it will stay in motion when it impacts another object.  Physics tells you that the heavier arrow will penetrate better, as does all of the Ashby testing and a whole bunch of dangerous game hunters.  This one is not even in question.  It is firmly proven.

[JDunlap]

Originally posted by JDunlap:
 

Originally posted by Ragnarok Forge:
JDunlap,  Heavier arrows do fly better in the wind.  Especially if you use HFOC and smaller fletchings.

Whittler,  A body in motions tends to stay in motion.  The heavier the body the longer it will stay in motion when it impacts another object.  Physics tells you that the heavier arrow will penetrate better, as does all of the Ashby testing and a whole bunch of dangerous game hunters.  This one is not even in question.  It is firmly proven.

[/b]

Thanks Rag,
That's what I figured about the heavier arrows and the hfoc, but the smaller fletching I didn't think of, makes sense.

[Ragnarok Forge]

There is definately a tipping point where more more weight slows the arrow enough to decrease penetration.  I believe that number is reached somewhere around 14 gpp.

[Friend]

My 2 cents which doesn't go very far this day.

We need to do some homework ourselves. Relying totally on what is being published may in fact be perfect for one and may be detrimental to others. My continued test in results have me temporarily parked at the upper middle of the road in referance to my own personal set-up.

It may not always easy to discern what Dr. Ashby's studies and results can be effectively applied to enhance our specific needs. We must do some of our own verification.

Different ggp rcommendations are recommended as having a bows maximum efficientcy maximized. Took Dr. Ashby ~17 gpp with a 40# @ 20# recurve to achieve very positive results on the buffs. My arrow speed estimation would be ~144 fps.

Personally I strive for the heaviest gpp, with my 51 -53# set-ups, that I can achieve that fits well w/i my site window at my effective hunting range and still be able to practise at moderatley extended ranges.

Note: Tuned and sharp BH's are assumed and my set-up may be modified according to particular species pursued.

Your own testing and verification will enable you to ascertain what is best suited for you.

[monterey]

Friend, well said.

[Thumper Dunker]

You think Ishi sat around wondering how heavy his arrow was. Im not sure how much my stuff weigh as long as they fly strait fast and blow through stuff. A heavy slow arrow is not as good as that same arrow going alot faster.