Originally posted by Bjorn:
However to arbitrarily blame the string material may be jumping to conclusions.
Ah...I hate to sound confrontational because I sure don't mean it this way...BUT, it is certainly not arbitrary. Neither am I jumping to conclusions. This is a direct result of FF material being used on a bow that was not meant for it.
I know some bows with wooden tips have handled FF strings without problem. That certainly doesn't mean that all will. Obviously some types of wood are better suited for that kind of force, this one wasn't.
ALSO, per the owner, the bow was not dry-fired. I realize that some guys are not truthful in a potentially embarrassing situation like this, but I know this gentlemen and trust his word.
I am not sure how many shots were fired before this happened. I can't even venture a guess.
The bow is a Wapiti. Keith has maybe as much experience as anybody in the world when it comes to building bows. He has seen this before in his and other people's bows. Keith is giving this customer a full warranty, even though his warranty wouldn't cover the use of a FF string or a dry-fire. It is an honorable move on Keith's part.
Like I said, I have not seen this in person before now. I have heard talk by reputable bowyers and bowhunters that this is exactly what happens. Tom, my Dad, has seen this happen to several bows when using FF with wooden tips. Exact same breakage.
Was the tip damaged or improperly made prior to breaking? I suppose there is no way to know for sure. However, since the bottom tip was cracked and also about to break, and since Keith is no spring chicken when it comes to building bows, and since my Dad and others have seen the exact same damage from FF, it is doubtful.
I put these pictures here purely for educational purposes. I figured many of you guys would be interested in seeing this. Lets not jump to any conclusions
No need to put down the bowyer or argue about potential causes. Nothing new here. It was an unfortunate accident. That's it.