Name the months you want them for. The Adirondacks can throw alot of things at you. And without snow, wet spots are a given in a 5 mile trek. I live in my Muck Edgewaters with various layers of wool up until significant snow pack, then into the Lacrosse or Sorel felt liner type for the cold. I like the lightness, comfort, support, of the waterproof Mucks for most of the year. The closest thing to my well loved Keenes I wear every day.
Just my opinion..... Boots are a personal thing.