I apologize if I steered this discussion off-topic a bit. It is very difficult to find wood arrows that will finish out at 32" bop. That is a super long draw length, have never personally known a recurve/longbow shooter with that long of draw.
Also, just wanted to clear up a few things...
First, I'm not (and don't claim to be) a hot-shot highly accurate shooter, just an average archer who loves to bowhunt. Second, I don't shoot bare shafts that accurately all the time, just sometimes. Third, I only posted the photo to show that wood arrows can be very consistent if they are spined the same, their weight is comparable, and they are well-tuned to the bow.
I believe it doesn't hurt to use an elevated rest either. I can't recall any bow I've owned that could group bare shafts as accurately off-shelf as they group off a rest.
But hey, we don't group arrows when we hunt and we don't hunt with bare shafts either... so shooting off-shelf isn't a bad thing. But I'm pretty sure those little doo-dads called arrow rests add a bit more consistency for me, regardless of the arrow type I'm shooting.
- Dave