People say great things about wilderness custom arrows. I make my own. I've used lodgepole pine, cedar, spruce, ash, and hickory.
Hickory is very tough, but warps easily.
Ash makes a great arrow, very tough and heavy, but is rather sluggish recovering after bending around the riser. Generally you'll need stiffer spine and/or larger fletching to get good flight with ash.
Cedar used to be considered the gold standard. It is easy to keep straight and flies well, but is a little on the light side and not particularly tough.
Spruce is tougher than cedar imo, and just as light. Some of my best flying arrows have been spruce.
IMO the best woods for hunting arrows are lodgepole pine and Doug fir. They are both pretty tough, recover quickly, are easy to keep straight, and about the right weight for hunting. of the two, I lean toward fir because surewood shafts does such a great job producing consistent, quality shafts.