All the reel styles work fine, but nothing shoots as well as an AMS. A pushbutton is good when the shots are short and the action fast, just MAKE SURE TO PUSH THE BUTTON BEFORE YOU SHOOT!!! It is easy to push the button, bump the handle and have it reset and shoot without pushing the button again. I prefer an AMS for most of my bowfishing. It is very durable, foolproof to use, quick enuf and nothing shoots as well as an AMS.
I also tie to the back of the arrow when using a pushbutton. Keep the slack short and if you haven't pushed the button the arrow will pull off the bowstring when you draw, a good reminder to push again.