Lots of solid advice here that will all be taken into consideration. I tuned before referencing the calculator, so I won't depend on it to land me where I need to be. I will, however, say that I may have been way too concerned with these arrows flying and hitting differently than what I usually shoot (506 grains of Beman Classic MFX), to the point that I have been tweaking my form, grip on the bow and a host of other factors that I believe have just thrown me off psychologically. For the last 20 minutes of daylight Tuesday, I reminded myself that I need only shoot, rather than thinking deeply about the shot execution. The arrows flew much better and a lot closer to my point of focus on the target.
Thanks for all of the responses to this topic. You all have given me plenty to think over while I'm not shooting.