Happy you got it figured out.
I didn't mean to sound snide with my comments. It's just that I have seen quite a number of folks go down a bad road with paper tuning, and was trying to head you off that trail.
I have a good friend who is quite an accomplished recurve & longbow shooter, BUT he is a convert over from the compound. I watched him completely go bonkers one time, and even start trying change up his finger hold on the string trying to get a bullet hole tear through the paper. He started shooting off his finger tips, and it completely ruined his shooting for a while. Once he started understanding what string roll & paradox meant to a finger shooter, he got back to normal fairly quickly. All this aggravation he suffered trying to get bullet holes in the paper when his arrows were already perfectly tuned.