I have used all the selways, love them all but only use the slide on since my quiver never comes off the bow. The strap on model is nice if you can't get the slide on down to the fadeouts, or if you want to swap it from
Bow to bow, leaving the arrows in the quiver holds it together almost like a a one peice, also if looks are a concern you can call Gordy and he will try and find something or atain something for what tou are lookig for! I am sure they are all great products but I'm partial to selway products, hard to beat the reuptation and lasting quality just don't let the dog get ahold of it hahaha!