okay you only have shot gift arrows or your own arrows? do you have a single arrow that you shoot that flys and hits perfect??? I say this because if you do then just send that arrow in a tube to Ted fry, elite, snag or other arrow makers here and they will match the spine, weight, ect.. you just pick the colors, fletch style, and so on..
as far as arrow material? if your stumpin and hunting my 1st choice would be snag's surewoods, they are tough and finish at a perfect hunting weight.. elites,, are cedars and just as fancy but I won't stump shoot with my elites they seem delicate but for shooting thru fur they are good.
Raptor's by Ted fry I have not shot them but I have heard nothign but good stuff,,,,now if you do not have a arrow to send then BEFORE you order wood arrows order or borrow a test set to try because what people recommend and what works for your style can be way off..