I know this thread pretty much has run it's course, but I decided to spare the system and not open another topic.
These are the three quivers that I have one had right now:
On the far right is the one I bought from HHA, my latest creation is in the middle and the one on the left is first one I made. I just wanted to show the differences in color between the three.
I'm assuming that the HHA quiver was made from oil tanned leather since it is the same deep color inside and out.
My first quiver was treated with two applications of Obenauf's Heavy Duty LP, which I just happend to have on hand. This treatment is similar in consistancy to with SnoSeal. It went on nicely, but didn't darken the leather very much, so I picked up some Obenauf's Leather Oil. This gave it a bit more color with just one application. I decided to leave this one as is for now.
On my latest quiver, I just used the leather oil. Man, but that oil soaks in fast! I swabbed some on one side, and before I could get back to work it around with my hand, it was mostly soaked in. This left it a bit splotchy. I went around it a couple of times, adding oil in the lighter areas and working it in by hand. I let it sit for a couple of hours, and then went at it again. It still has some light spots, but it still looks pretty good. One more treatment, and it should be a nice even brown color. I like the lighter color of the fold-down with a single application of oil. Might leave it like that for now.
I'm going to Anchorage this afternoon, so I plan on swinging by Tandy's to get a 1/8" lacing needle, and to look as some oil tanned leather. Might keep just keep going at this open ended winter project!