tuning dilema

[10point]

Today I shot bareshaft arrows of 2 different spines and got 1 hitting straight and 1 severly nock left. They hit the target in the same place.
I tried paper tuning the same spines with feathers and got perfect bullet holes.
So, I have conflicting results from 2 tuning methods and am unsure how to react. Any suggestions ???

[McDave]

If I'm reading your post correctly, your results were not conflicting.  Bare shaft indicated one of the shafts was too weakly spined.  Paper tuning didn't indicate a preference for one or the other.  So pick the stiffer spine.