Bows with shelves cut past center, because they permit the center of the arrow to get closer to the center of the bow, will shoot a wide range of spines as long as one doesn't under spine. Can overspine almost indefinitely. The closer to centershot they are, the less the arrow has to flex as it passes the shelf. That's why one can overspine so much with that type of bow.
However, lining the arrow up such that the string perfectly bisects the shaft is not good for finger shooters. It works OK for wheelie guys with triggers, who induce very little sideways string movement at release.
If it's lined up directly on center, the arrow doesn't know which way to flex at release, and will be erratic depending on the quality of the release. Generally, finger shooters will do better to line up the arrow so the right side of the point lines up with the left side of the string, for a right handed shooter. Vice-versa for a lefty. Such an alignment does require a bow cut quite a bit past center, though it may not need to be 3/16 of an inch, depending narrow diameter.
Regardless, I think that's what you found and reported on in your second post, DanielB. Your arrow is actually lined up a little left of center. Doubt it would shoot as well for you if it was perfectly centered. If you have enough room to thin your side plate, give it a try and let us know the result.