20-30 years ago all I used to dip cedars in was bohning fletch-lac, and it worked great. A short foray into gasket lacquer showed me it was neither as tough as real lacquer nor the look I sought. I drifted away from making pretty arrows for a number of years. When I started back in I was doing much more shooting with carbons and even aluminums. I just find no satisfaction with arrow wraps! I tried a number of the new products on the market-enamels, waterbased dips,etc. I found those finishes were not as bright nor as bomb proof as I remembered Fletch lac had been(and a few old cedars left around from the old days proved it. So I decided to endure the toxic odor again and went to Fletch lac. Ya know what? It's still bright and bomb proof, and I'm going to keep using it. Works fine on carbon...not over other finishes, but I've capped and crested over it with other finishes and they also turned out fine. But, if I've got the stink from dipping, why not use real fletch lac cresting paint and be done with it?