Both are my go to bows, but after receiving Brian's redesigned recurve limbs I have not been able to put my 60" long riser curve down.
With that being said the Stickflinger is really special and the best shooting longbow I found for myself. Zero hand shock and super quiet. I have always been a recurve guy myself, but the last two years all I hunted with was my stickflinger if that tells you anything..
In the end the stickflinger is still a longbow, a hybrid one, but a longbow. If you want it to act like your recurve it won't, but it will shoot like a dream!