If you are looking for a really easy 2 piece that looses nothing for looks and feel, look at the Robertson Stykbows. Whether an ASL or a mild R/D would be best for you, may depend on how you shoot. If you shoot with a straighter bow arm, you may prefer the Robertson longbow over an ASL. Of course, even if your shooting form resembles Howard Hill the R/D will work, it all depends on one's personal strengths and weaknesses. I have two weaknesses, my draw length varies about a half inch depending on stature and shooting position, and sometimes I have a very hard release. In other words a 30 yard shot can be off 5" with one of my ASLs, but may be 10" with my R/D. Not all ASLs are created equal, I feel that mine are above average, same goes for mild R/Ds. I suppose a good compromise would be to get an R/D where your draw length would come in at the lower end of the optimal draw for that bow length. I have made good longer shots with both, but when it comes to the fast and furious creatures like rabbits and pheasants, I am better with my particular ASLs. I know, I was responding to both of your threads..