Let me see if I got this right, you have been shooting field points and judos for some time, you even bareshafted but until today you have not shot a broadhead out of your set up? I would be you a cup of coffee that you are under spined. and now you have a hunt in a few days and are panicing.
I am sorry, I may sound harsh, but I cannot for the life of me figure out how someone can go all year or summer and not make sure that big ole wind plane up front is shooting were it should after all the initial tuning was done.
I shoot a 54 and 55 pound longbow (Savannah and Crusader) and my wood arrows are 65/70 spined for 125 grain heads and fly perfect. I would suspect you need 65-70 or 70-75 arrows or go down on head weight.