First of all, let me say, I am no shooting guru. I don't pretend to be able to advise other folks on shooting styles or problems, considering I still have a ways to go myself. Occasionally, however, I have a "eureka" moment and want to share.
Take this for what it is; something that may seem natural and instinctive to most folks may be overlooked by others -- Like me! I'm from Missouri after all. Sometimes, you have to "Show Me!"
So... Here's my little epiphany in a nutshell: Keep your string hand and wrist in alignment with your string. That simple!
Ever since coming back to traditional archery a couple of years ago, I've struggled with consistency. Some days I can't miss, other days I can't hit squat. Some days my arrows fly like the proverbial dart, other days they waggle like geese! Lately, the bad days have been outnumbering the good days. Of course, I looked to my form for problems. "Well, I collapsed a little bit on that shot." -or- "I dropped my bow arm that time." -or- "Focus dummy! Concentrate! Look at what you want to hit!!!"
Here's what changed a couple weeks ago... I've been shooting a "long" longbow for a while now, but I recently switched to a shorter bow. Very quickly, I noticed some soreness in my ring finger, and a distinct callous where there was none before. I searched posts here on Trad Gang for similar problems, and read advice from various people on what the problem could be... "Elbow to high" "Torqueing the string" etc... I believe I've had my little problem from day one, but switching to a shorter bow, and correspondingly sharper string angle, just aggravated the problem to the point that I started noticing it more.
I've also been looking at posts recently where guys talked about arrows hitting the shelf, and poor arrow flight. For most of these, the advice was clear; "you're over-spined." Well, I knew my arrow spine was (or should be) okay from bare shaft planing, yet most of my accuracy problems looked like symptoms of an over-spined arrow.
Quickly, a word about bare shaft testing. I've read that the bow should be vertical when using this method for arrow tuning. Sounds sensible to me, so that's how I do it. Well, it's easy for me to keep my wrist and hand vertical, but when I shoot normally, I 'cant' the bow. Herein lies the problem.
I figured out that a majority of the problems I was having came from not keeping my string hand in alignment. I was canting the bow, but not my string hand. My string hand was still too vertical. The area of my "hook" on the string was looking like this -- S -- instead of this -- / -- (right handed shooter).
As soon as I started concentrating on keeping my string hand in alignment with my bow, my accuracy and my arrow flight improved dramatically!!! Now I know that some of you will nod sagaciously and say, "well that's just common sense!" ...and I agree! But sometimes it's easier to look at a problem from a distant perspective than it is to diagnose a problem when you're the one having difficulty shooting.
Most important to me, is that even when I don't execute my shot perfectly, I'm hitting much closer to my mark than I was a few short weeks ago. I don't know if this post will help anyone or not, but my hope is that someone will benefit. If you love to shoot longbows and recurves, there's no better feeling in the world than to see a perfectly round ball of feathers spinning into your target.
As a side note, I'll add that keeping everything in alignment is much easier for me when I focus on it from the beginning of my draw. Especially when I get a little tired from prolonged shooting sessions, I have to remind myself to keep everything lined up and solid. I think the tendency, for me at least, is to turn the wrist in towards the body when fatigue sets in.
Have fun. Shooting is fun, but good shooting is m0-fun!!!