You should see two arrows, the fact that one is in line with the arrow and the other is not is what is important. Being right handed and left eye dominant to a degree, the right eye has become stronger. I have the same thing, no dominant eye, and I am somewhat ambidextrous. I shoot better fast right handed, I am right handed mostly, and I shoot better slower left handed, although I can speed up some and still shoot fine. If your head is tilted a bit the higher of the two indirect arrows you should be the one over the arrow. The left indirect arrow when shooting right handed, while you are holding the bow in your left hand, and the right arrow when holding the bow in your right hand. If you make a switch, start out shooting slowly with good full draw power. you can even play around with indirect sighting, however, the longer you do it the less you will notice that you are intentionally placing your arrow and it will become more of an automatic reflex, instinctive. To bad you are not near here, I have a number of right handed bows that I am looking to part with. The only thing is that when I give someone a free bow I want to personally hand it to them and make sure that it is the right bow that person.