Whichever you get, just be sure the fit is snug. A glove probably should start out feeling a little too tight, and work into snug over several uses. Fingers should reach the ends of the gloves, with no loose material at the ends. Tabs should not be wider than the width of your three drawing fingers, and only long enough to reach about halfway down the pads of your last finger joints, so that your fingertips extend beyond the end of the tab when your fingers are extended.
My observation is that tab/glove preference runs about 50/50, with maybe a slight preference for gloves. However, once people decide which they like better, they don't tend to switch back and forth much.