TIM
You cannot possibly ramble on too much for me. I enjoy every word. It is great to have a site like this where those of us that share a common interest can meet and chat. Also, I have been known to ramble a bit myself.
I agree that a single sale of a bow will not set the price of other bows of that model. I disagree that rarity is not a major factor. I believe in the below formula
R X I X C X OF = $Value
Where R = RARITY
I = INTEREST
C = CONDITION
OF + OTHER FACTORS (+/-).
Bear bows probably corner the market in the INTETREST catagory. That is because A) there are so many of them, and B) because Fred Bear probably did mor to stoke the interest of archeyr than any ever, living or dead. Of course other brands such as Pearson, Wing, Widow, Hoyt, Howatt, Herter's, Shakespeare, and others also own their fair share of that catagory. I know of several collectors that only collect Herter's or Shakespeare bows.
Then you get into the Staghorns, Groves, Drakes, Sabos, Tice & Watts, Howard, Brackenbury, etc... These bows where not as common as the others, but they were certainly high quality, and are really sought after by some collectors. I have an "NE TELLUM" which is even more uncommon.
Another factor for consideration is if the BOWYER is still making bows, or even still living. BRACKENBURY bows made by Jim are sought after as collectibles. Now Bill Holland is making the BRACKENBURY bows and they are sought after as SHOOTERS. ElRod is now making the GROVES bows. It is sad to say, but the old quality bows are like works of art. The value goes up after the artest has departed. We have lost many of the quality bow makers over the years. Thank God that bowyers like Holland, Elrod, Morrison, Palmer, Assenheimer, and far to many others to mention have come along to take their places.
If we all had to depend on our own ability to make bows, I would be shooting a solid Bamboo bow. That would be a Bamboo fishing pole bent with a sting on it. I have to admire anyone that can make a good recurve, even from a Bingham kit.
As a collectible, and as a shooter, my all time favorite is the Jack Howard GAMEMASTER JET. That bow goes back to the early '80's, but Jack has been making bows since the '50's, and is still making them. If I am not mistaken, the JET came out in about 1983 at a price of $200.00. You can still get a brand new one exactly like the original but it will cost you $1,000.00 each. I just picked up a used 49# JET for $460.00, and that was a bargain. I have seen them sell for over $600.00, used. Jack is trying to retire and his company is up for sale, to include three months of training in his unique methods. I sure hope somebody continues his line, because I hate to see his JETS and CLASSICS come to an end.
As far as rarity goes, it comes down to simple economics. "Supply and Demand". If there is a lot of interest in a rather RARE bow, the price is not going to be low, in any brand.
Not that I am trying to hold up the value of my personal collection, because I don't intend to sell off my good collectibles. They will be left to my grandson. I should be saying that any bow from the '60's (the golden years of recurves,in my opinion) is worth only ten bucks each, because I am a buyer, not a seller. I have a rare desease. I consider myself to be a RECURVE-A-HOLIC. It is a sad degenerative desease that only gets worse with time. The degenerative part is to the checkbook - devastating.
I bought my grandson two recurves, but he outgrows them so fast that now I just let him shoot out of my collection. How many 10 year olds are out on the 3-D range in the CUB division shooting a 35# STAGHORN. Not many, I'll bet. He has no concept of what he has in his hand. To him, it is just an "OLD BOW". At a 3-D shoot in Georgia last year he saw a lady with a new, beautiful ACADIAN WOODS BOW. ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS. He says to me, "PaPaw (that is cajun for GRAMPAW), I want one of those for Christmas". Yeah, Right!! I'm gonna spend that kind of bucks to buy a bow that fits him at 10 years old for him to outgrow in a year. I told him to save "HIS" money for one. His next bow is scheduled to be a 40# 1964 KODIAK in great condition.
Now I have to concede that when it comes to collecting bows, I will probably have to defer to your superior knowledge, as a collector. However, when it comes to "RAMBLING ON", I can hang in there with the best of them
TAKE CARE
JACK