I have used both, unless I am wading water, I will always go with the schnees, I dont think ya can find a better boot. If I had the $$ I would have a uninsulated (which I have) and a pair of insulated, I like the 16" boot with my pant legs tucked in, if you take care of them they will last ya several years, Burleys usually last 2-3 years for me. If ya are thinking scent control, I actually think the schnees are better in that a rubber boot actually makes ya sweat more, and "stovepipes" the odor, up and out of the boot.. My opinion.. good luck.. Dave