Jason, I built several bows on a 68" mild R/D form (which I think is similar to a critter getter). I will tell you my results of each build..maybe it will help. Overall, I think .004 total taper is the way to go.
Here is a build along I did on one and you can see the form design and tiller I achieved with .006 per lam:
http://tradgang.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=125;t=000558 That one was 68" long and it shoots great after a bunch of fine tuning on the tiller. A friend of mine made that form and his best shooters also had .005 to .006 total taper per side.
I made another bow on the same form, used .004 total taper per lam, 66" shot better than the Paduak bow.
I made a 3rd, carbon fiber back..69" .004 total taper per side...a little shocky on the hand...but I suspect if I go back and re-tiller it to even I could eliminate some of that shock.
I think .002 or .003 total taper per side would be way too little for my form. I think next glue up I am going to try .005 total taper per side with carbon on the back.
good luck