Shooting an elk calf??

[LongbowArchitect]

I used to hunt elk antlers when I was young and harvested some big bulls. After a while I came to realize that I was just as happy getting a nice dry cow and they tasted better. Although I've never shot a calf I would definitely not rule it out.

[pavan]

If you were in a difficult spot, they would be easier to pack out.  Tastes way better than antler stew.  i would only shoot a great big bull if I was concerned with preserving my man status. 

[GCook]

My father in law always says “ never pass on the first day what you would shoot on the last day!”..

True but I have passed many an animal on the last day and had a tag to take home.  Shooting a fawn/calf is like giving up.  Granted later in season. They have a bit more size and weight.  Early archery they are mighty small though.

Sent from my SM-G892A using Tapatalk

[Wannabe1]

I've yet to harvest my first anything so, if it's legal and edible, I've no qualms with anything.

[Don Stokes]

My first elk was a calf that weighed maybe 250# on the last day of the hunt. It was the best wild game meat I've ever put in my mouth!

[kadbow]

Not for me, no good reason, they still seem small during archery season. No problem shooting a year old cow.

[two4hooking]

No elk hunting opportunities close to here.  My family and I make big sacrifices for me to chase elk for a week in September.  I've been every year for over 10 years without a kill (despite some wonderful opportunities), and if I have a calf in my wheelhouse with no better chance at something bigger.... its days are numbered.  I am doing it public land and DIY.....the hard way.

I will be looking hard for Mamma first though.

Everyone has their own perspective on trophy and what they will shoot.

[Don Stokes]

Agreed, two4. If you live in elk country it's a different decision. On a scheduled hunt with no other chance, a calf looks pretty good by the end of the week.

[wingnut]

Over the past 55 years of elk hunting I've taken a few calves.  Usually it was either late in the hunt or mistaken identity.  I do have to say that calf eats very well.  I'd rather put a calf in the freezer then buy beef any day.

Mike

[Don Stokes]

Right on, wingnut.

[Doug Treat]

I've taken a calf before. My buddy had just shot a cow and I took her calf. I estimated that it weighed about 300#. It was bigger than any mule deer I've taken. Definitely easier to pack out than a big elk but if I had a choice between a big elk and a calf, I would take the most meat.

[MnFn]

My chance at taking elk theses days is very limited.  I was drawn last year for my once in a lifetime elk in ND so that door is closed.

If I get the chance to go to hunt CO elk with my son again, I’ll shoot any legal animal. Love that elk meat.