we all like different things i guess, when we wanted a new tent- i spent a lot of time looking at options.
my criteria were, and in no particular order
1. cost
2. weight
3.ease and speed of pitching
4.withstanding storms
5. internal space
we live up here in teh PNW, in a temperate rain forest, it always rains, just the angle changes
i wanted a tent that could go up in minutes in the rain, easy to pitch by myself, a woodstove- space for wet gear and wet tracking dogs!!
i find wall tents take too long to pitch- and i dont think they handle the weather that well with the big slab sides, internal space is good, but you have to carry a bunch of poles for an internal frame, or cut poles on site.
i took a page out of history- and really like the tipi idea- in design alone( except for the tiny door)
tipi and pyramid tents are great- quick and easy to set up- handle the weather better- but they have a sloped and very exposed doorway, and also a lot of space is lost around the edges.
i needed something that offered the best of both worlds!!
i eventually, after a few years of searching came across the Bell tents!!
and they fit the bill in all regards.
they are basically a conical tent ( tipi) with short cottage walls ( better space utilization).
only have a single central pole.
they have a very large door that is vertical- and well protected from the elements.
mine came with a heavy duty zip in groundsheet.
they are super-fast to pitch- i can have mine up and people inside in maybe 2 minutes- others can then be setting up the stove, unpacking etc, while i wander around the outside and set the short, 2' to 3'guy lines.
the process is so simple- i simply roll out the tent- peg the floor down, take the 3 piece pole, lift the canvas- go in and push the pole up to the apex. done!!!-
its now an erect tent albeit a bit droopy. but its usable and self standing!!
then i pull the short side guys at the eave where the slope joins the cottage wall, and set them- that pulls the sides out, tightens everything up- and generates a lot of space.
that maybe takes another 10 minutes or so, so in essence i can pitch the tent by myself in under 15 minutes.
very affordable too- i think i paid 700 canadian for an 18 footer.- and we have been using it hard for the last 7 years- still ,looks great- and no tent failures yet.
they have a range of sizes- we bought the 5m- sometimes its too big, and sometimes its too small- but in general its just perfect.
it folds up into its own sausage bag, with carry handles- maybe 3' long and 16" diameter, incl pegs and poles!!
https://www.belltent.co.uk/shopi use a simms folding stove- its great- we used them when i was wrangling in the rockies- and really like their simplicity, compact design, general sturdiness and affordability.
i bought extra stove pipe and put the flue where it best suited me.- i like the stove near the door- so i am not packing firewood everywhere- but to the side- so it doesnt impede traffic- really happy with its position.
i know they will stitch in the flue where you want it.
https://www.walltentshop.com/products/sims-stovescurrently i am in the process of building a light weight canvas, no groundsheet tent based on the kifaru sawtooth type tent- just bigger and with a bigger stove- for two on a remote canoe moose hunt- i wanted less weight and bulk than my Bell tent- but with all the comfort of a canvas tent- i am really happy with how the project is developing.