Our local club just had our annual pheasant shoot yesterday. We use broadheads or Pierce small game heads, almost exclusively. Pointing dogs are also used, and if there is an arrow in the bird, are told to stay, and then the shooter retrieves the bird. Been doing this for years and years with no problems. We use mostly Bodkin factory seconds, since we lose a few, but I did notice a few guys were using Snuffer, Ribteks, etc. Although I never have shot a pheasant with a judo point, or a blunt, I have seen ptarmigan fly off with judos in them, never to be seen again. I suppose if you made nothing but head shots, a blunt or judo would be the ticket, but I know I'M not THAT good...
Incidentally, my son Chase got his first one yesterday and we will be having it for dinner tonight.