Silver Sticks:
That's my old home-town. Grew up on Spruce Way (off Coddington), by Ithaca College.
You have Danby state forest that sees little archery pressure, but is run over with gun hunters. The bow hunters that I have experienced travel little in from the road. You should also consider Arnot forest. Cornell manages it (earn a buck program) and there are applications, fees, and sign-in/out requirements, but also results in a drop in pressure. Numerous other areas, but you will be sharing the woods with the whole outdoor population. Look into the vinyards, they hate the damage the deer do.
Tough part is that there aren't lots of large tracts of land anymore there. Also a strong anti-hunting contingency.
I no longer hunt the area, as my hunting partner in that area recently moved. Good luck!