Tree342 - I'd recommend paper testing at 15 feet. At 2 feet, the arrow isn't even close to being out of the major bending. It needs a bit of distance to quiet up some. Your arrow is not coming out of a centre-shot compound with mechanical release.
I try to paper-tune for coarse tuning & cross-check, then bare shaft for fine tuning.
Emphasis on "try"
Orion's got it; start a bit too high, then you know where it's coming from. Make small changes in your nock heights.....sometimes it is VERY sensitive!!!
A horizontal 1" paper tear is perfectly acceptable in some circles, good luck to you.