The level of comfort is most important. I shoot bows under 50# and the tab gives me a cleaner release (not subjective for me). There is no right or wrong answer here, it's what works for you. I recently found some of the old Neet calf hair models from the 70's and have enough to last awhile. I used a Damascus glove for awhile and liked it, but for me they are more problematic in cold weather.
Jeff...I use a tab over my middle finger over my regular gloves in cold weather. However, I don't wear heavy gloves, even in the coldest of weather. I can flip the tab back against the palm of my hand and warm my hand in a coat pocket. Works for me.