Dustin, I have recently discovered how nice a finish you can get with Devcon clear epoxy, found at Walmart in hardware for about 2 bucks. It is called 2 ton clear, by Devcon, in the syringe type gizmo. Squirt, mix, and dab your rubber gloved finger in it, and wipe on the knife handle. Hang it handle side down, and in 10 minutes, wipe the drip off...it will heal itself. Ends up wet-looking glossy. I prefer satin, so wet sand it a few seconds with wet/dry 1000 grit sandpaper, then buff back out with rubbing compound until the sheen suits you.
The finish is VERY hard.
Dan