Caleb,
That was not "one depressin' evening," that was ONE WONDERFUL EVENING! It's all a matter of perspective. You had a close encounter with three beautiful creatures, and an experience you will never forget. That's a very successful night. A successful shot would have been sweet icing on the cake!
On every hunt I attempt, I am hoping for a Close Encounter... a chance to be in the "personal space" of a wild animal without being detected. It's a wonderful thing when it happens, and some of my very favorite hunts of recent years were ones where I chose not to release an arrow (or could not). It is a thrill to be "in amongst 'em," and THAT constitutes a win in my book!
I was blessed/fortunate/outright lucky(?) enough to take four deer with my recurve last year. They provided a year's worth of meat budget for my family. My fondest memories of the year, though, were two hunts where I could have shot, came to full draw, and decided not to let the arrow loose. It would be too long a story to explain the specifics in one post, but it was... GREAT!
It is great to kill a deer, but you can have a LOT of amazing hunts before... and after... that happens.
"I'm not going to give up because the season is only 5 days old"? Man, I sure hope not. You'd be cheating yourself out of some memories that could last forever!
Be patient, and keep after 'em!
Best wishes,
Daryl