Like you I have used a home made GFA style quiver for well over 20 years....guess I should have marketed it. Oh, well.......
A couple of years ago Laura and I bought a 23 acre piece of land that is landlocked and we only have an old logging road or a canoe paddle to get to it. I sweat easily so I invested in a fleece Day One pack to carry my clothes in so I could finish dressing at my stand. I found the GFA quiver to be a bit on the noisy side, the Cat Quiver just didn't work with the pack and a bow quiver was just too heavy on my DAS bow. I sold all my commercially made quivers and got the Arrowmaster. It works great with my pack, I can pretty much throw it around in the canoe, it protects my fletch and is my go to quiver. The fact that I can put a knife, a rope, spare hooks, and other stuff in the pocket makes it a no brainer if I want to take a quick scouting trip but don't want to lug my back pack around. I replaced the rubber in the bottom of the quiver with a more dense foam. The only two draw backs I have with it is that when I carry a judo it tends to dull my bhs. Secondly, getting a second arrow out of the quiver after a miss can make a bit more commotion than the GFA. But I have learned how to hang it in a tree so that problem is minimized and I also partially "release" the second arrow so it is not stuck in the foam and comes out easily. Given all the pros and cons of all the quivers out there I think the Arrowmaster is the best choice. I use my homemade GFA quiver in my Double Bull blind.