There was no choosing involved. As George stated, in the beginning, it was archery and bow hunting. Then came the beast (OK so I am getting a bit theatrical here.)
I started with various "stick" bows and went over because of the sales pitch, "it is better, more accurate, more power, better for the critter," etc and much more rubbish.
I came back because it just feels right. Not to prove any points, not to do it the hard way, none of those, it was just ....me.
Most of the folks I hunt with feel the same. I wonder. . is that because I turned them on to "trad" or because we just tend to hang with people with similar interests ?
ChuckC